Colo W Va gamblers could be nabbed for child support
Deadbeat parents, listen up: Win big at the casino tables in West Virginia or Colorado, and your kids might win, too.
The two states are moving ahead with plans to garnish the winnings of casino gamblers who owe child support. West Virginia's Department of Health and Human Resources is working on a plan that could be in place within 90 days, while Colorado is rolling out its system July 1.
The proposals are another tool in a diverse arsenal that authorities already have to collect money from delinquent parents.
"We impose the same burden on banks; they must search their records. We do the same thing with brokerage houses and other businesses. Welcome to the club," said state Rep. Joel Judd, a Denver Democrat who fought for five years to overcome industry opposition and win approval from legislators.
"I'm not aware of anyplace else in society where we have large cash transactions like we do at the casinos," Judd said. "It just seemed to me that if a guy owes back child support and wins big, the kids ought to get the money."
Colorado's plan faced significant opposition from casino operators who argue it is difficult to track table winnings, and West Virginia is hearing the same. Critics say the programs impose an undue and unenforceable burden.
"A person could actually come to the casino, purchase $2,000 worth of chips, cash out $1,000 worth of chips, and it would look like he won $1,000. But the truth is, he lost $1,000," said West Virginia Racing Association President John Cavacini. "There's no system in place that would compute winning and losing."
Currently, the Internal Revenue Service requires casinos to report large payouts - over $600 on most forms of wagering, over $1,200 on slot play - but Cavacini said it is the obligation of the gambler to report income from table games.
The IRS also requires casinos to report cash prizes over $5,000 in tournaments and non-cash prizes worth more than $600.
While many states check big winners of traditional lottery games against lists of people who owe child support, the National Conference of State Legislatures believes Colorado and West Virginia would be first to go after casino winnings. Mississippi and New Mexico have statutes allowing casino payouts to be intercepted for child support debts, but neither is doing so.
Budget problems stalled development of an electronic interface in Mississippi, where child support officials also couldn't get an agreement with the casinos, said Stephanie Walton, a program manager for the National Conference of State Legislatures.
The New Mexico Department of Human Services, meanwhile, can track winnings and match them to a list of delinquent payers, but it has no way to collect the money. Spokeswoman Betina Gonzales McCracken said the state simply gathers information on payouts over $1,200 as evidence for court hearings.
Nor is there any way to predict how many people such systems would snare: Casinos are tourist destinations, and each state checks names and Social Security numbers against only its own database.
In the Colorado and West Virginia systems, casinos would garnish the winnings of delinquent gamblers on the spot - a prospect Judd said operators found unappealing.
"I told them, there is no other line of business better equipped to handle an angry customer than yours," he said.
But there are differences in the states' plans: While Colorado would go after all forms of winnings, West Virginia would initially focus only on table games.
West Virginia may target slots later, said Garrett Jacobs, deputy commissioner of the state child support bureau. But it must first determine how to apply the system to about 1,600 video poker bars.
Allowing employees at those clubs to access a secure system could compromise personal information, Jacobs said. The state also believes it would be unfair to force child-support checks on the four casinos without requiring the same of the smaller parlors that compete for their customers.
In Colorado, legislators passed a law to implement the new program. But in West Virginia, child-support officials are trying to bypass lawmakers. Because the West Virginia Lottery lacks jurisdiction to enforce the child-support plan, however, its success depends on the casinos' willingness to participate.
Spokeswomen for Wheeling Island Hotel-Casino-Racetrack and Mountaineer Casino Racetrack & Resort in Chester, W.Va., said they know too little about the plan to comment. But an executive with Tri-State Racetrack & Gaming Center in Nitro, W.Va., which will soon install table games, said collecting child support would be a hassle.
"I can certainly understand the problem, and I'm certainly sympathetic to the problem. But I'm also running a business," said Daniel Adkins, vice president of the casino's parent company, Michigan-based Hartman & Tyner Inc. "It seems like quite a burden to put on the operator."
Adkins said he would rather collaborate on a system both parties could live with, such as a periodic list of offenders' names that could be distributed to the casinos.
"We're partners in the state, no question about it," he said, "and I'm sure we could come up with a reasonable solution."
Join the discussion The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from personal comments and remarks that are off point. In order to post comments, you must be a registered user of MiamiHerald.com. Your username will show along with the comments you post. Not a registered user? It's Free! Register here
Free forum sponsored by the Chinese Texas Hold em forum for members of the first activities sponsored by the Forum identity of the members of the Forum through the link registered poker site will be free of sponsorship applications. Sponsor-free deposit will be transferred directly into the Member The poker accounts.
All of this forum for free gift only for members of the development plan, members can be certified to participate in the activities of the Forum priority.
Forum members identity
It is only through the Forum link address for registration to account for UB; Need to enter a user name, surname, name, mail order enquiries; UB full-commission for a minimum quota of 25 U.S. dollars; Anti-commission will direct you to the account of the UB; Anti-commission of a monthly update on the 1st;
Credits for cash
will now begin the forum will be divided into two points, points and rewards Fund Forum
Forum integral how to get it is: the Forum and registered 50 points, a theme integral plus 5 minutes, plus 1 back to the theme integral points, posting the best points and adding 50 points, the annex to upload pictures points plus 5 points to participate in the forum to vote Integration activities at 1 pm, the forum moderator at the right post to the other plus points: 10-30 minutes each ranging from best of posts: 50 minutes.
Forum Rewards Points how to get it is: the end of every forum to post selected number of high-water, long-time online Star, best original author of the article and personal best of the best blog content blog. Forum award points to 50 -- Ranging from 100 points.
Rewards Points can directly exchange the RMB. Convertibility ratio is 1:1. Member for dollar reward points, the Forum will be transferred to the appropriate accounts to pay-points and the Forum Forum Rewards Points can be mutual conversion, the conversion ratio of 100 points
